Bin it or Keep it?

Two more from today's shoot. I really like these two photos, but the shadow on the face caused by the tree is too distracting, I think. I used SB800 with LSPJ II (with inverted dome) pointed straight up with flash comp. of -1.0. Obviously this was not enough for the fill effect on her face (position of the flash should have been different). I think next time I will use sb800 on a tripode as remote fill directed at the point were tree meets the face. Is it the way to avoid such a shadow? I will endevour to re-shoot this one in the future. However, do you think these two shots are rubbish or worth worth keeping?
and for the record, I prefer No.2.
Thanks.
Alex


and for the record, I prefer No.2.
Thanks.
Alex