DSLRUsers.com

Hey guys/girls.

I've been into photography for around 8 months now. I started with film and currently I am using a pentax p30n for my shots, coupled with a 50mm 1.7, 28-200, and a 24 2.8 macro/wide. I'm making the switch to digital soon with a d70s!

I'd like some critique on some of my portraits, just general critique. Composition, lighting etc.






All shot on film. Neopan 1600, Ilford XP2 400, or Agfa Ultra 100 across all shots.

I'd really like some critique on them!

If you wanna check out more pics of mine to give some crit then feel free to check my flickr, in the sig.

Some of the pictures of the young female has uneven lighting on the face. Its gives a baggy shadows under the eyes. It is very evident in the first two shots.

4,5 and 6 are good composition and I dont know if the excessive noise is intensional.

Male guitarist is splendid.

Last one the background is too overwhelming.

nito wrote:Some of the pictures of the young female has uneven lighting on the face. Its gives a baggy shadows under the eyes. It is very evident in the first two shots.

4,5 and 6 are good composition and I dont know if the excessive noise is intensional.

Male guitarist is splendid.

Last one the background is too overwhelming.

The first two pics were taken in a food court in the city, so as you can imagine there's lights all over the place.

as for 4,5,6.. They were taken with the Neopan ISO1600 so noise is a given

Thanks very much for the comments!

Compositionally, i like the images a lot, except the last one which is a bit lacking, perhaps it's her bored look.

There is a contemporary magazine style to your work, which some will love and others will hate, but either way the images are very good.

I really like 5 and 7 compositionally. The noise adds to the style.

Alex

Don't get hung up on depth of feild, pay attention to "depth of feel"

The last two images have something interesting happening for them, the other images are merely pretty photos of a girl.

Antsl wrote:Don't get hung up on depth of feild, pay attention to "depth of feel"

The last two images have something interesting happening for them, the other images are merely pretty photos of a girl.

That girl being my partner, so naturally they look 100x better to me

But thanks mate.

I have to admit, I do go a bit DoF Crazy sometimes. I was still getting the hang of the 50mm 1.7 then, not quite realising how shallow 1.7 was!

vort - some great shots IMO here, I agree with Steve that you have captured a contemporary maganzine feel that I quite like. The second last one of the muscian (guiarist?) is my favourite, I wouldn't change a thing with it. Some of the shots of your partner are great too, how does she feel about them, and about being infront of the camera, looks like she's atleast a willing model.

Look forward to seeing what you can produce with a digital camera.

this is excellent work they all have a great feel to them

these two are your best, composition, expression and lighting


but this one is standout, the shallow depth of filed slight artistic blur
and the dramatism


thsi one has a nice expression but somehow maybe the composition or contrast it lacks something the others don't have


the others don't live up to the other ones because of the compsoition and expression on the subject, but i am sure you will nail these quickly on your next tey

your use of blur, noise, out of focus parts of the image, tone and composition are on the right track

Thanks alot wendellt. Very appreciated

I will still shoot film for B&W when I get my Digital. Nothing can compare to the feel of proper B&W Film. I love it

The top two could use a little fill flash to get rid of that lighting.

The others are good. The guitarist is the most interesting. Probably unintentionally blurry, but worked in this case.